DEV Community

Cover image for Classes in JS: Public, Private and Protected

Classes in JS: Public, Private and Protected

bhagatparwinder profile image Parwinder 👨🏻‍💻 ・3 min read

Even though ES6 introduced the class keyword that fairly well mimics classes and allows us to jump into object-oriented programming, JavaScript is missing the ability to create public, private, and protected members in a class.

If you have worked with any object-oriented language, you must know the importance of internal vs external interface. Internal interface refers to the methods and properties of a class that is only accessible by the class itself and not from outside. In contrast, the external interface has methods and properties that are also accessible from outside the class.

The three major keywords at play are public, protected, and private.

  1. Public: These members of the class and available to everyone that can access the (owner) class instance.
  2. Private: These members are only accessible within the class that instantiated the object.
  3. Protected: This keyword allows a little more access than private members but a lot less than the public. A protected member is accessible within the class (similar to private) and any object that inherits from it. A protected value is shared across all layers of the prototype chain. It is not accessible by anybody else.

The protected keyword is the hardest keyword of the three to imitate in JavaScript.


This is the default nature of JavaScript. If something has access to an object, it does have access to its members. Example:

const myObject = {
    name: "Parwinder",
    sayMyName: function () {

console.log(; // Parwinder
console.log(myObject.sayMyName()); // Parwinder

In the above example, I can access the property and method without any issue. If you would rather prefer it in a class syntax:

class ObjectCreator {

    constructor(name) { = name;

    sayMyName() {

const myObject = new ObjectCreator("Parwinder");
console.log(; // Parwinder
console.log(myObject.sayMyName()); // Parwinder


There are multiple ways of creating private variables in JavaScript. First is closures.

function carMonitor() {
    var speed = 0;

    return {
        accelerate: function () {
            return speed++;

var car = new carMonitor();
var redCar = new carMonitor()
console.log(car.accelerate()); // 0
console.log(car.accelerate()); // 1
console.log(redCar.accelerate()); // 0
console.log(redCar.accelerate()); // 1
console.log(car.accelerate()); // 2
console.log(redCar.accelerate()); // 2
console.log(speed); // speed is not defined

car and redCar maintain their own private speed variables, and speed is not accessible outside. We are enforcing the consumer to use the methods defined on the function or class rather than accessing the properties directly (which they should not). This is how you would encapsulate your code.

The second way is by using the # notation.

class ObjectCreator {

    constructor(name) {
        this.#meaningOfLife = 42;

    returnMeaningOfLife() {
        return this.#meaningOfLife;

    #returnAMessage() {
        return "You will do great things in life";

const myObject = new ObjectCreator("Parwinder");
console.log(myObject.returnMeaningOfLife()); // 42
console.log(myObject["#meaningOfLife"]); // undefined
console.log(myObject.#meaningOfLife); // SyntaxError
console.log(myObject.#returnAMessage); // SyntaxError

The language enforces encapsulation. It is a syntax error to refer to # names from out of scope. Public and private fields do not conflict. We can have both private #meaningOfLife and public meaningOfLife fields in the same class.

🚨 The # method for declaring private members of a class is in part of ES2019/ES10.


Like I said at the beginning of this post, protected is the hardest of all 3 to implement in JavaScript. The only way that I can think of doing this is by using a class that has a getter for a property without a setter. The property will be read-only, and any object will inherit it from the class, but it will only be change-able from within the class itself.

🙏 If you have an example of creating protected members of the class (or as close to protected as we can get), please do share!

class NameGenerator {

    constructor(name) {
        this._name = name;

    get name() {
        return this._name;

let nameGenerator = new NameGenerator("John");
console.log(`My name is ${}`); // My name is John = "Jane"; // Cannot assign to 'name' because it is a read-only property.

Discussion (2)

Editor guide
ashleybooniphone profile image
ashleybooniphone • Edited

I have managed to emulate an extended protected class (somewhat) using a function that contains ES6's magic to destructure an Object from another function and an Object.assign to extend the Object on return.

The code in question:

shadowtime2000 profile image
shadowtime2000 • Edited

For protected variables you could also kind of use what was used for private variables with a function.

function NameGenerator(name) {
var publicData = {name};
var privateData = publicData;
return {...publicData, john() {return NameGenerator("John")}};

Though I don't have any good idea on how to actually change the values instead of creating a new object;