Good article! One comment: you should quote your variables, like this: "${myvar}". Google "bash quoted variables" for lots of discussion on this topic.
As an aside, unless I'm distributing something where I know someone might not have bash, I think it's fine to use bash for scripts. For example, everyone at work should have bash installed, so if I'm scripting there, I'll use bash. If it's intended for Linux and not Unix, I'll use bash, and let people either translate it or temporarily install bash if they don't have it installed for some reason (I think they should - it's a de facto community standard). I even installed bash on my router because not having its extensions was driving me insane.
Thanks! I thought that only variables without curly braces should be wrapped in quotes. I'll update the article later to include this, thanks for the advice.
I agree on using bash for #! as most of my scripts, for now, are just for mine own usage, and I guess that all my friends at least have the bash shell on theirs PC-s if not actively using it.
Another thing that I've noticed is that with #! /bin/bash, if the user doesn't have it installed, the error will be something like: cannot find command: /bin/bash and the user can install it in mere minutes instead of getting a cryptic message I got because of using #! /bin/sh when I've experimented with shell functions and spent another 15 minutes trying to resolve the issue.
Shellscripts that will be used in production env, it may be a bit better to use #! /bin/sh but that can fail too, so there is no right answer I guess.
If you're using #! /bin/sh you have to be POSIX compliant, otherwise you might destroy something along the way, because you cannot know what shell you are running on.
If you are relying on bash built-in, obviously you have to specify that, otherwise you might again destroy stuff.
Good article! One comment: you should quote your variables, like this: "${myvar}". Google "bash quoted variables" for lots of discussion on this topic.
As an aside, unless I'm distributing something where I know someone might not have bash, I think it's fine to use bash for scripts. For example, everyone at work should have bash installed, so if I'm scripting there, I'll use bash. If it's intended for Linux and not Unix, I'll use bash, and let people either translate it or temporarily install bash if they don't have it installed for some reason (I think they should - it's a de facto community standard). I even installed bash on my router because not having its extensions was driving me insane.
But that's just me ... YMMV.
Thanks! I thought that only variables without curly braces should be wrapped in quotes. I'll update the article later to include this, thanks for the advice.
I agree on using bash for
#!as most of my scripts, for now, are just for mine own usage, and I guess that all my friends at least have the bash shell on theirs PC-s if not actively using it.Another thing that I've noticed is that with
#! /bin/bash, if the user doesn't have it installed, the error will be something like:cannot find command: /bin/bashand the user can install it in mere minutes instead of getting a cryptic message I got because of using#! /bin/shwhen I've experimented with shell functions and spent another 15 minutes trying to resolve the issue.Shellscripts that will be used in production env, it may be a bit better to use
#! /bin/shbut that can fail too, so there is no right answer I guess.If you're using
#! /bin/shyou have to be POSIX compliant, otherwise you might destroy something along the way, because you cannot know what shell you are running on.If you are relying on bash built-in, obviously you have to specify that, otherwise you might again destroy stuff.
For example, regarding scripting:
stackoverflow.com/questions/100672...
Lots of other discussions around, but that should get you started.