DEV Community

loading...
Cover image for New benchmark: Mezon Router VS Power Router

New benchmark: Mezon Router VS Power Router

alexdodonov
PHP developer
Updated on ・7 min read

Hi all! Today we have one more benchmark.

As usual we have two cases:

  1. http server accepts request, launches php script, which handles this request, and then all script data is removed from memory. All following requests are processed in the same way. In this case very critical to launch script as soon as possible and we do not have time for long pre-compilations and preparations. Because all of it will be lost after the script will finish working;
  2. php script is launching, initiating all internal components (and router is one of them) and then starting processing requests. This case can be organized via for example react-php. It differs from the previous case because we can spend reasonable time to pre-compile routes for faster processing.

The first case

// static routes
$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/static/0';
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerStaticRoutes(1000);
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/static/99';
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerStaticRoutes(1000);
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/static/199';
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerStaticRoutes(1000);
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());
// and so on up to /static/999 route
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
// non static routes
$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/param/0/1/';
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerNonStaticRoutes(1000);
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/param/99/1/';
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerNonStaticRoutes(1000);
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/param/199/1/';
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerNonStaticRoutes(1000);
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());
// and so on up to /param/999/1 route
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

The second case

// static routes
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerStaticRoutes(1000);

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/static/0';
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/static/99';
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/static/199';
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());
// and so on up to /static/999 route
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
// non static routes
$router = RouteGenerator::generatePowerNonStaticRoutes(1000);

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/param/0/1/';
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/param/99/1/';
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());

$_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] = 'GET';
$_SERVER['REQUEST_URI'] = '/param/199/1/';
$request = ServerRequestFactory::fromGlobals();
$router->start($request, new Response());
// and so on up to /param/999/1 route
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

OK What do we have?

The first case + static routes

+------------------------------------+-------------+-----+------+-----+-------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------+
| benchmark                          | subject     | set | revs | its | mem_peak    | best          | mean          | mode          | worst         | stdev        | rstdev | diff    |
+------------------------------------+-------------+-----+------+-----+-------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------+
| CoffeeSingleRequestStaticBench     | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,936,232b  | 41,057.300μs  | 84,148.370μs  | 47,592.655μs  | 249,780.200μs | 74,221.744μs | 88.20% | 48.66x  |
| DVKSingleRequestStaticBench        | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,392,992b  | 25,714.700μs  | 26,682.450μs  | 26,362.514μs  | 28,618.500μs  | 819.301μs    | 3.07%  | 15.43x  |
| HoaSingleRequestStaticBench        | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,847,864b  | 44,176.400μs  | 47,097.030μs  | 45,321.883μs  | 63,058.400μs  | 5,365.782μs  | 11.39% | 27.23x  |
| IBSingleRequestStaticBench         | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,471,624b  | 126,073.700μs | 130,365.100μs | 128,767.356μs | 143,720.600μs | 4,833.922μs  | 3.71%  | 75.39x  |
| MezonSingleRequestStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,287,376b  | 9,073.900μs   | 9,357.890μs   | 9,297.606μs   | 9,896.300μs   | 236.985μs    | 2.53%  | 5.41x   |
| MiladSingleRequestStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 33,649,608b | 29,915.300μs  | 30,749.180μs  | 30,291.549μs  | 33,174.000μs  | 977.528μs    | 3.18%  | 17.78x  |
| PeceeSingleRequestStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 7,085,072b  | 36,595.500μs  | 37,232.050μs  | 37,031.929μs  | 38,438.600μs  | 554.518μs    | 1.49%  | 21.53x  |
| PowerSingleRequestStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,862,216b  | 19,049.200μs  | 20,140.870μs  | 19,808.905μs  | 21,000.000μs  | 643.417μs    | 3.19%  | 11.65x  |
| SteampixelSingleRequestStaticBench | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,566,392b  | 207,734.200μs | 210,574.660μs | 210,950.748μs | 212,526.200μs | 1,389.866μs  | 0.66%  | 121.77x |
| ToroSingleRequestStaticBench       | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 1,745,216b  | 1,476.200μs   | 1,729.290μs   | 1,583.368μs   | 2,666.700μs   | 346.981μs    | 20.06% | 1.00x   |
+------------------------------------+-------------+-----+------+-----+-------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------+
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

The first case + non-static routes

+-----------------------------------+------------+-----+------+-----+--------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------+--------+
| benchmark                         | subject    | set | revs | its | mem_peak     | best          | mean          | mode          | worst         | stdev         | rstdev | diff   |
+-----------------------------------+------------+-----+------+-----+--------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------+--------+
| CoffeeSingleRequestParamBench     | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,903,272b   | 53,137.000μs  | 53,669.140μs  | 53,434.041μs  | 54,304.600μs  | 398.649μs     | 0.74%  | 4.85x  |
| DVKSingleRequestParamBench        | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,385,376b   | 29,081.100μs  | 30,110.190μs  | 29,726.930μs  | 31,490.000μs  | 755.289μs     | 2.51%  | 2.72x  |
| HoaSingleRequestParamBench        | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 4,165,464b   | 45,786.400μs  | 46,825.120μs  | 46,833.564μs  | 47,952.800μs  | 583.437μs     | 1.25%  | 4.23x  |
| IBSingleRequestParamBench         | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,592,344b   | 145,910.100μs | 147,746.210μs | 147,306.262μs | 150,106.800μs | 1,239.601μs   | 0.84%  | 13.36x |
| MezonSingleRequestParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 139,508,728b | 124,171.600μs | 126,109.060μs | 125,425.730μs | 130,917.500μs | 1,915.883μs   | 1.52%  | 11.41x |
| MiladSingleRequestParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 34,508,144b  | 35,645.000μs  | 36,320.080μs  | 36,141.269μs  | 37,270.600μs  | 527.261μs     | 1.45%  | 3.28x  |
| PeceeSingleRequestParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 6,669,256b   | 75,824.900μs  | 84,586.110μs  | 78,820.332μs  | 109,839.700μs | 10,653.230μs  | 12.59% | 7.65x  |
| PowerSingleRequestParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,862,216b   | 20,937.700μs  | 28,584.620μs  | 24,077.098μs  | 40,265.800μs  | 7,123.452μs   | 24.92% | 2.59x  |
| SteampixelSingleRequestParamBench | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,666,344b   | 235,446.700μs | 348,940.010μs | 297,900.248μs | 691,357.600μs | 128,878.867μs | 36.93% | 31.56x |
| ToroSingleRequestParamBench       | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 1,866,176b   | 9,774.800μs   | 11,056.990μs  | 10,512.857μs  | 12,358.000μs  | 835.968μs     | 7.56%  | 1.00x  |
+-----------------------------------+------------+-----+------+-----+--------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------+--------+
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

The second case + static routes

+----------------------------+-------------+-----+------+-----+------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+-----------------+---------------+--------+------------+
| benchmark                  | subject     | set | revs | its | mem_peak   | best          | mean          | mode          | worst           | stdev         | rstdev | diff       |
+----------------------------+-------------+-----+------+-----+------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+-----------------+---------------+--------+------------+
| CoffeeReactStaticBench     | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,409,400b | 7,916.900μs   | 8,434.210μs   | 8,309.219μs   | 9,401.900μs     | 425.183μs     | 5.04%  | 410.30x    |
| DVKReactStaticBench        | benchStatic | 0   | 100  | 10  | 2,652,296b | 10,289.710μs  | 10,796.560μs  | 10,512.391μs  | 13,365.110μs    | 864.430μs     | 8.01%  | 525.23x    |
| HoaReactStaticBench        | benchStatic | 0   | 100  | 10  | 2,893,936b | 3,576.030μs   | 3,622.525μs   | 3,606.191μs   | 3,731.710μs     | 43.214μs      | 1.19%  | 176.23x    |
| IBReactStaticBench         | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,034,880b | 25,829.300μs  | 26,309.220μs  | 26,380.221μs  | 26,774.000μs    | 303.353μs     | 1.15%  | 1,279.88x  |
| MezonReactStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 100  | 10  | 1,908,208b | 18.630μs      | 20.556μs      | 18.987μs      | 25.150μs        | 2.436μs       | 11.85% | 1.00x      |
| MiladReactStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 5,275,192b | 15,524.100μs  | 16,269.690μs  | 16,402.613μs  | 17,264.100μs    | 511.121μs     | 3.14%  | 791.48x    |
| PeceeReactStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 4,243,936b | 19,101.900μs  | 20,167.700μs  | 19,701.218μs  | 22,467.300μs    | 1,012.717μs   | 5.02%  | 981.11x    |
| PowerReactStaticBench      | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,029,632b | 15,172.800μs  | 15,635.430μs  | 15,559.212μs  | 16,680.100μs    | 397.706μs     | 2.54%  | 760.63x    |
| SteampixelReactStaticBench | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,605,560b | 239,026.100μs | 346,973.110μs | 250,424.922μs | 1,209,825.800μs | 288,217.061μs | 83.07% | 16,879.41x |
| ToroReactStaticBench       | benchStatic | 0   | 10   | 10  | 1,734,616b | 351.800μs     | 382.130μs     | 364.151μs     | 480.600μs       | 39.107μs      | 10.23% | 18.59x     |
+----------------------------+-------------+-----+------+-----+------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+-----------------+---------------+--------+------------+
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

The second case + non-static routes

+---------------------------+------------+-----+------+-----+------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------+
| benchmark                 | subject    | set | revs | its | mem_peak   | best          | mean          | mode          | worst         | stdev        | rstdev | diff    |
+---------------------------+------------+-----+------+-----+------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------+
| CoffeeReactParamBench     | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,409,368b | 8,548.600μs   | 9,257.830μs   | 8,950.739μs   | 10,758.200μs  | 640.445μs    | 6.92%  | 6.19x   |
| DVKReactParamBench        | benchParam | 0   | 100  | 10  | 2,656,688b | 14,344.960μs  | 18,446.126μs  | 16,842.581μs  | 31,828.310μs  | 4,840.866μs  | 26.24% | 12.34x  |
| HoaReactParamBench        | benchParam | 0   | 100  | 10  | 3,360,824b | 3,862.030μs   | 4,972.977μs   | 4,750.023μs   | 6,237.760μs   | 730.301μs    | 14.69% | 3.33x   |
| IBReactParamBench         | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,157,360b | 43,412.000μs  | 59,080.640μs  | 54,258.725μs  | 95,701.400μs  | 14,431.920μs | 24.43% | 39.52x  |
| MezonReactParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 100  | 10  | 3,129,488b | 1,178.510μs   | 1,494.984μs   | 1,341.991μs   | 2,096.520μs   | 283.938μs    | 18.99% | 1.00x   |
| MiladReactParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 5,402,688b | 22,573.900μs  | 28,562.900μs  | 24,596.006μs  | 49,765.900μs  | 8,124.021μs  | 28.44% | 19.11x  |
| PeceeReactParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 4,625,032b | 47,438.500μs  | 53,523.160μs  | 49,062.308μs  | 71,146.100μs  | 8,897.750μs  | 16.62% | 35.80x  |
| PowerReactParamBench      | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 3,029,632b | 16,629.600μs  | 17,320.220μs  | 17,040.916μs  | 18,338.400μs  | 523.710μs    | 3.02%  | 11.59x  |
| SteampixelReactParamBench | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 2,664,712b | 250,206.800μs | 270,897.140μs | 256,660.290μs | 299,426.700μs | 16,652.239μs | 6.15%  | 181.20x |
| ToroReactParamBench       | benchParam | 0   | 10   | 10  | 1,785,112b | 8,329.400μs   | 8,866.510μs   | 8,599.075μs   | 9,795.400μs   | 478.527μs    | 5.40%  | 5.93x   |
+---------------------------+------------+-----+------+-----+------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------+
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

As you can see in some cases Power Router is the fastest router, in some cases it is not, but still shows good results.

What's next?

More articles can be found in my Twitter

What is mezon/router?

mezon/router now is:

  • framework for routing with 100% code coverage
  • 10.0 points on scrutinizer-ci.com
  • router is a part of the Mezon Project

Repo on github.com: https://github.com/alexdodonov/mezon-router

It will be great if you will contribute something to this project. Documentation, sharing the project in your social media, bug fixing, refactoring, or even submitting issue with question or feature request. Thanks anyway )

Discussion (2)

Collapse
james69452776 profile image
James

As always, you could consider participate in this benchmark
github.com/the-benchmarker/web-fra...

Collapse
alexdodonov profile image
alexdodonov Author

Looks interesting. Thanks!