DEV Community

Cover image for Rejection & Revision: On Improving Conference Proposals

Rejection & Revision: On Improving Conference Proposals

Alaina Kafkes on October 23, 2017

One of my goals for 2018 is to speak at more tech conferences. Although I gave talks at two conferences in 2017, the call for proposals (CFP) proc...
Collapse
 
amandasopkin profile image
Amanda Sopkin

Thanks for writing this Alaina!! I love the analogy to clubs/spades/hearts/diamonds. Do you have any advice on how to know whether a proposal is worth revising or should be scrapped altogether? It's hard to know whether an idea is good and worth building on, or whether it would we better to go a different direction.

Collapse
 
alainakafkes profile image
Alaina Kafkes

Hi Amanda! 👋

That's a great question. I think that a speaker-hopeful should scrap their talk proposal if a change in their personal interests makes them decide that they no longer want to speak about a subject. A speaker may also choose to scrap their proposal if they receive feedback that makes them want to approach a subject from a new angle.

However, I'm of the opinion that most rejected conference talk proposals bring forth good ideas. Sometimes, these ideas need to be revised or brought to a different venue in order to be beneficial to both the audience and the speaker.

Collapse
 
amandasopkin profile image
Amanda Sopkin

Thanks! I like that perspective/advice.

Collapse
 
mary_grace profile image
Mary Thengvall

This is a fantastic post! Thanks for taking the time to write all of this out in such detail... it's a difficult topic and you've laid it out in a very actionable way. Much appreciated!

Collapse
 
wiredferret profile image
Heidi Waterhouse

Alaina, thank you for your clear ideas about how to accept feedback and incorporate it. I'm still working on that skill myself!

Collapse
 
anjuan profile image
Anjuan Simmons

This is a great post, Alaina! Thanks for sharing. You've helped me upgrade my abstract game. :-)

Collapse
 
alainakafkes profile image
Alaina Kafkes

Thank you, Anjuan! I admire your talks so this means a lot. :)