DEV Community

Discussion on: Programmatic Navigation in React using react-router

Collapse
wintercounter profile image
Victor Vincent • Edited on

The article completely misses the hooks way (useRouter).

You should stick to the declerative way whenever you can. I think the article should endorse this to be complete.

Collapse
dance2die profile image
Sung M. Kim
  1. You should not redirect from a Redux action. Actions should not have side-effects.

Would checking for a Redux state and redirect on state change/value be a good way?

Collapse
wintercounter profile image
Victor Vincent

I updated my comment as it was bs :) For some reason I had reducers in my mind all along.

Collapse
kustomdesigner profile image
Michael Hicks

Any negative effects from redirecting using local state?

Collapse
projectescape profile image
Aniket Author • Edited on

I've updated the post, would really appreciate if you check it out!

Collapse
wintercounter profile image
Victor Vincent

Good job!

Collapse
projectescape profile image
Aniket Author

Thanks for the comment.
I'll try to update the article as soon as I can.