I am a web kind of guy.
I have been a web kind of guy since a computer technician told me it was too hard for a kid to make a website in the 1990s (yes I still remember you, piece of shit, look at me now!)
But I have also tried many other things through the years, one of them being creating Desktop Applications.
I used heavily VB6 in High School, and I loved it, I tried many other things through the years, WinForm C# being the last one I was working with before completely losing interests for Desktop apps.
The main reason why I stopped was that I could just WebApp everything, why bother doing loads of crap, learning new languages to generate an exe file if a website would just do fine?
In the last 10 years, that approach seems to be taken by pretty much everyone, thanks to Electron.
You write a web app, yes, but you can present it as if it was a native app, bundling a chrome browser with the exe file and showing HTML instead of native components.
The good thing about that is that you can use a set of languages you are familiar with (javascript, HTML, and CSS), and out of the box your app is multi-platform, as every stinking OS can run a Browser nowadays.
The only cons of that are:
- Relatively Big App (~100 Mb) even for relatively small apps.
- Quite a lot of RAM is used even for relatively small apps.
In Modern Computers (fucking hate that word for how much is used) RAM and size of a binary should not be a problem, but I am not a Modern Computer, I am a guy with selective OCD, and the fact that I need to write HTML and ship my desktop app with Chrome bundled it really "grind my gears".
So since I am a sucker for learning new languages, I have been recently learning Dotnet again (on Mac and Linux) and I was curious to see if there were any framework that would allow me to go full Native Desktop app dev, but keeping a low impact on a system.
I found and learned (this is how I learn) AvaloniaUI.
Which is nice to work with once you get used to XAML and you forget everything you know about reusable components.
I did a couple of side projects:
- A Calculator using their MVVM tutorial.
- A stinking TODO List App, following another tutorial but adding a persistency layer.
- Another fng football manager game (it is in a private repo).
- A small Password Manager - Muscurd-I (because EpicGames and Ubi Launcher kept logging me off and I needed something local to store my passwords).
The Avalonia community is quite nice also, they have a discord server, but they are mostly active on Telegram.
They have been really helpful and I have also been contributing to their doc website.
I found only one small problem.
Guess how big is the binary for the app (if you make it self-contained and bundled up with all the DLLs and external deps)?
~100 Mb ... 😞
So yeah even though it will be dear to me and I might still work on some stuff with it again, I feel like I will be learning something else now.
The next adventure is called Vala. It is like a C#-like language that compiles down to C but it includes GLib (which is GNOME low level wrappers around C API).
It looks like it was half abandoned but then gained again some contributors.
Let's see how it goes.
Top comments (8)
Have you looked into Tauri? I'm not a Desktop apps programmer by myself, but I heard that it fixes the shortcoming of Electron
oh I did not. Will look into that a bit more it looks promising
You got Flutter for all platforms
oh yeah that's what I decided to look into next, seems quite hacky. like a nicer react native
You should consider trying Go and the Fyne toolkit. Much smaller apps, no dependencies and fast rendering too.
Good shout, I had tried fyne in 2020ish, will try it out a bit more thanks
Be sure to join our Slack or Discord communities if you have questions. Just like the Go community the group is super helpful.
tried and made a new post about it, if you are interested in some feebacks