re: 😲🤯The most outstanding new feature in Javascript you need to know about: Optional Chaining VIEW POST

FULL DISCUSSION
 

This is probably the worst proposal ever. It will allow to write even shittier code in JS.

Rather than solving the problem by better code design, devs will use this crappy shit.

 

Okay, why is this crappy?

What do you mean with better code design?

Please explain a little bit more what you mean.

 

You are retrieving some data from API. Till you retrieve the data, you should have something like data: null, after you get data from API, you should have the whole object.

API should always return you a predefined object structure, right? So once data !== null, you should be able to access all properties and deep properties instead of checking every object in your structure.

I understand that there might be some valid cases where object?.property?.property might be a shorter code, but it doesn't mean it should be implemented in the language.

Once this is in language, the syntax will be overused and more shitty code will be written.

What if the API is not in your hand and you have no control over it?

I don't see it being overused in ruby or c# or any other language. Why should this happen in JS?

Assuming that objects returned from third-parties conform to a specific structure (and therefore, not 'verifying' their structure and the presence/lack-thereof of expected properties) is most-likely a security blunder.

Sorry, I don't fully understand what you mean.

 

A better pattern would be to use Option/Maybe or Either.

If I have something like:

var a = null;

rather than using a?.b I would use:

const a = fromNullable(a);

const aValue = a.map(_ => _.b).getOrElse("No value");

You can further chain like

a.chain(_ => .b)
.chain(
=> .c)
.chain(
=> _.d)

In your anti-corruption layer convert all nulls to Option/Maybe and you don't have to deal with nulls.

I would love to not deal with null/undefined in JS.

I find the ?. really elegant.

But I also find Ruby elegant where things like this are normal.

code of conduct - report abuse