How would you setup a model in Rails to reference the same model type?

twitter logo github logo ・1 min read

Let's say I have a model for a thing called "Chapter". I want to be able to reference the next chapter and the previous chapter for each chapter. How would you go about setting this up?

So what I'm looking for is something like this:

c = Chapter.first

c.next_chapter should return a chapter object that is the next chapter.

twitter logo DISCUSS (13)
markdown guide

# in migration
def change
  add_reference :chapters, :previous_chapter, foreign_key: { to_table: :chapters }

# chapter.rb
belongs_to :previous_chapter, class_name: β€˜Chapter’
has_one :next_chapter, class_name: β€˜Chapter’, foreign_key: :previous_chapter_id

Thanks Brian for the reply!

has_one :next_chapter, class_name: β€˜Chapter’, foreign_key: :previous_chapter_id

Why is the foreign_key the previous_chapter_id and not something like next_chapter_id?


Because that’s a reference to the database column in your migration. That line basically says, β€œWhen the :next_chapter method is called, return the chapter that lists this one as its :previous_chapter.”

You could set up the migration to store the next chapter instead of the previous one. It’s the same process. I just thought it makes more sense this way because when you create a chapter, the previous one probably exists already, whereas the next one might not.

Ahhh clever, thanks Brian for the help. I implemented this method and it worked as you described it :)


in your app/models/chapter.rb

def next_chapter
  return self if self == Chapter.last 

  Chapter.find +1


The first line checks if the chapter that you called next_chapter on is the last one and if so, it just returns itself (You can change this to an error message or whatever you want). And if that's not the case, then we call find on chapter, which takes the Chapter ID as an argument and we just add one to the current ID. And voilΓ : Now you can call next_chapter on your Chapter instances


Thanks Miguel for the tip on setting up the method :) this is super helpful.


I would go with Brian’s solution then. The other solutions work, but I would prefer to have a strong reference, in this case a foreign key stored in the Database.

Yup that's the solution that I ended up going with. Thanks Christopher for the help!


Assuming a Book class exist and it has many chapters, and also assuming that the chapter has a position number stored in the database, I'd do something like:

class Chapter < ApplicationRecord
  belongs_to :book

  def next_chapter
    book.chapters.find_by(position: position + 1)

  def previous_chapter
    book.chapters.find_by(position: position - 1)

I'd question whether a method like this should sit in the model (should it actually have knowledge of its sibling persisted objects? Usually not)

Depending on your context, making a small class/service/whatever which determines position might be more suitable (and easier to test/maintain).

Classic DEV Post from May 1 '18

Are Technical Interviews a good measure of software engineering ability?

Sarah Mei @sarahmei Why do we keep doing whiteboard interviews, even though...

Michael Lee πŸ• profile image
Maker of things, giver of high-fives πŸ–