Should You Customize Your Resume for Every Job? Here's What I Learned After Applying to 100 Roles

Job hunting can feel like a never-ending maze, especially in today’s market. Some experts swear by tailoring your resume for every job, while others say it’s all about quantity. Curious about what works best, I decided to conduct an experiment. I applied to the same 50 jobs twice—once with tailored resumes and once with a generic one—and the results were eye-opening.

The Experiment: Tailored vs. Generic Resumes

Here’s how I approached it:

1. Tailored Resumes:
   
   I meticulously customized my resume for each of the 50 job descriptions. This involved aligning my skills, tweaking my experience, and rewriting parts of my summary to match the job requirements. It took about 30 minutes to tailor each resume and another 15 minutes to fill out the job application details.

   • Total Time: 45 minutes per job.
   • Results: 6 interview calls (a success rate of 12%).

2. Generic Resumes:
   
   For the same 50 jobs, I sent a one-size-fits-all resume—no customization, no tweaking. Filling out the application details still took 15 minutes per job.

   • Total Time: 15 minutes per job.
   • Results: 4 interview calls (a success rate of 8%).

By comparing the results from the exact same set of jobs, I could clearly see the impact of tailoring.

The Numbers: Time vs. Success

• Tailored Resume Approach:

  • Time Spent: 45 minutes/job × 50 jobs = 2,250 minutes (37.5 hours).
  • Success Rate: 6/50 = 12%.

• Generic Resume Approach:

  • Time Spent: 15 minutes/job × 50 jobs = 750 minutes (12.5 hours).
  • Success Rate: 4/50 = 8%.

By tailoring my resume, I got 2 more interviews, but it came at a steep cost—25 extra hours of work.

What Does This Mean for Job Seekers?

The key takeaway here is that while tailoring your resume improves your chances slightly, the effort required might not be worth it unless it’s for a role you really want. On the flip side, using a generic resume saves time—time you can use to apply to even more jobs.

Let’s Do the Math

• Time Saved by Skipping Tailoring:
  
  2,250 minutes - 750 minutes = 1,500 minutes (25 hours).

• Potential Jobs You Could Apply For in 1,500 Minutes:
  
  100 more applications!

If we assume a similar success rate of 8% for generic resumes, applying to 100 more jobs could yield 8 additional interviews, making up for the lower success rate.

My Recommendation

Here’s my advice based on this experiment:

1. Tailor for Dream Jobs:
   
   If you come across a role that’s a great fit (you meet 80% or more of the required skills), take the time to tailor your resume. These are the jobs where effort can make a real difference.

2. Go Generic for the Rest:
   
   For roles that are a stretch or less appealing, stick to a generic resume. Focus on volume and efficiency.

3. Freshers, Focus on Quantity:
   
   If you’re just starting your career, casting a wider net will likely serve you better. The more applications you send, the higher your chances of landing an interview.

Final Thoughts

Tailoring your resume may feel like the “right” thing to do, but the returns aren’t always worth the time invested. By saving the 25 hours I spent tailoring, I could have applied to 100 more jobs—and potentially landed 8 extra interviews.

The choice is yours: Is a 12% success rate worth all that extra effort, or would you rather boost your chances with more applications?

For me, the answer is clear. Tailor selectively and apply broadly. Today’s job market demands both strategy and efficiency.

What’s your approach? Have you tried something similar? Let’s discuss—I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences!

Want More In-Depth Content?  

If you enjoyed this post and want to dive deeper into topics like this, follow me on Medium for exclusive and more detailed content.  

Stay connected, and let's grow together! To the Moon 🚀