Which should you use? Array.from vs. Spread Operator

I had a conversation with a coworker about the merits of using spread ... vs Array.from. While they look the same on the outside, they work differently.

Iterable vs. Length

If you want to spread something into an array, it needs to have a Symbol.iterator property.

This means that the following Javascript will fail:

const spreadObject = [...{ user: 'jane' }];

Even though this would work:

const user1 = {
    user: 'eloise'
};

const updatedUserInfo = {
    lastLogin: 'today'
};

const user1New = {
    ...user1,
    ...updatedUserInfo
};

The solution would be to add a [Symbol.iterator] generator function to the object, which is honestly not worth it.

Array.from creates an array if the object has either an iterator or .length property.

Built in mapping function

Have you ever seen a snippet like this:

const mappedArray = [...arr].map(item => {
    // do stuff to item
})

Did you know that that creates 2 arrays? Array.from has a built in mapping function though.

const mappedArray = Array.from(arrLike, item => {
    // do stuff to item
})

I find this helps keep things more explicit, especially when you are not using an inline function.

const approveUser = (user) => ({
    ...user,
    approved: user.age > 21
});

const allApprovedSpreadUsers = [...users].map(approveUser).every(user => user.approved);

const allApprovedMappedUsers = Array.from(users, approveUser).every(user => user.approved);

Do you need to care about making that extra array? Probably not, but it is a neat thing to remember.

Which do you use?

I usually reach for Array.from. The spread operator is very useful when getting n arguments from a funciton, and spreading objects into another is priceless.

const mergeUserInfo {
    ...userFromSource1,
    ...userFromSource2
};

function approveMergedUsers(user1, ...otherUsers) {
    // do user stuff
}

Either way, I think Array.from is worth keeping in your tool belt.