DEV Community

Mingchun Huang
Mingchun Huang

Posted on

Robot parts that passed inspection but would not assemble

A robot customer once sent back a set of parts and said every dimension was in tolerance but the assembly would not close. They were not being difficult. Each piece had a inspection report, each piece was legal, and yet when you put the three together the holes did not line up.

The problem was datums. Each part had been made to its own drawing correctly, but the drawings referenced different features. The errors were all small and all in the same direction, so they stacked instead of cancelling. Every part passed. The assembly failed.

Inspection reports do not assemble

That job changed how we look at multi-part assemblies. Now, when a customer sends a set that has to fit together, we ask to see the mating parts, not just the individual drawings. Sometimes we make a simple check fixture that holds the pieces in their real relationship. It is not high technology. It catches the thing the reports cannot.

I have had buyers resist this because it feels like extra work before a price. But it is cheaper than a batch of parts that are all correct and all useless together.

Where the tolerance number stops helping

A tolerance tells you how far one feature can wander from its nominal. It does not tell you how three parts will behave when you stack them. That is a system question, and it needs a system answer — shared datums, a stack-up check, or a physical fit test. We learned to ask for those on robot assemblies after the batch that would not close.

The honest version is that we missed it first. The drawings were legal and I trusted them too far.

What we tell buyers now

If you are buying several parts that have to fit as one assembly, send us the mating relationship, not just the part prints. We would rather quote a little slower and get the stack right.

We machine CNC robot parts and automation components in Shenzhen, with tolerances down to +/-0.005 mm where the drawing calls for it. More on our CNC robot parts machining.

CHX Precision Metal — precision CNC machining in Shajing, Bao'an, Shenzhen. MOQ 1 piece, prototypes 3-7 working days, batch production 7-15 days, EXW Shenzhen.

Top comments (0)