DEV Community

The Right Idea Becomes the Wrong Idea Over Time

Ben Halpern on August 30, 2018

2008: Don't build your server-side application with JavaScript. Are you f#@cking crazy? 2018: Build your server-side applica...
Collapse
 
alephnaught2tog profile image
Max Cerrina

Jeez, way to be a reasonable and respectful human being who focuses on bringing the community closer together instead of divisiveness.

JERK.

Collapse
 
mortoray profile image
edA‑qa mort‑ora‑y

I'm still happy to hate JavaScript. Despite being everywhere, and being useful, it's a mess of a language. It lacks just about every modern programming feature. It's horribly unsafe. It's still slow. It's bonkers.

Modern JavaScript is a flowery dress covering a mannequin made of trash.

Don't let the old joke die! :)

Collapse
 
zeddotes profile image
zeddotes

What's your preferred language?

Collapse
 
mortoray profile image
edA‑qa mort‑ora‑y

Depends on purpose. For web server APIs I'd use Python. For anything involving calculations, extended logic, or lots of code I'd use C++. For mobile I'd use Fuse system I worked on -- if it remains an option.

I only ever begrudgingly used JavaScript, TypeScript, etc. because I have no real option.

Collapse
 
guitarkat profile image
Kat

This is me. Let's use Edge. How about none of those options?

Coding for IE8 has been hurting my heart as a front end type of person. The personal hell of supporting old IE is painful. The job is hard enough. :p

Collapse
 
zeddotes profile image
zeddotes

Babel?

Collapse
 
speculative profile image
Jeffrey Tao • Edited

I've never really understood what seems to be large swaths of the developers posting on the internet who like to debate the relative merits of technologies or view certain technologies as illegitimate (see also: PHP). Widespread usage of something seems like an indicator of at least reasonable quality/soundness/viability, in my opinion.

Most choices of technology for a given problem are usually in some way a reasonable choice to make.

Collapse
 
perttisoomann profile image
Pert Soomann

"Eventually, when the opponent is challenged or questioned, means the victims investment and thus his intelligence is questioned. No one can accept that, not even to themselves."

Collapse
 
annarankin profile image
Anna Rankin

I agree completely! I showed a fellow dev one of my old Backbone/JQuery projects from a few years back recently - he's only worked with Webpack/Babel/React on the front end. I saw the abyss reflected in his eyes as he said, "Wow. ...Yeah. Yeah, we have it good nowadays."

(...though for what it's worth, I kind of miss Backbone and JQuery sometimes 😂)

Collapse
 
rrampage profile image
Raunak Ramakrishnan

Good ideas are always relevant e.g backwards compatibility, minimalism, accessibility, simplicity in design. Technologies and fads may come and go.

JS is an interesting amalgamation of ideas. The primary one (portability) was to make the web more interactive, without having the user install a separate software. Java applets, Flash, ActiveX failed at this. JS allowed for web pages to go beyond simple text, images and hyperlinks. Most importantly, JS allowed a generation of programmers to play around with code in the comfort of their browsers, thus lowering the barrier to become a developer. Now that it has become ubiquitous, ECMA and major browsers do not deprecate parts of the language, leading to efforts like typescript, the (old) coffeescript and an increasingly complicated JS to smooth over old mistakes.

The support for IE is a battleground for ideas. Will you break the web for a section of your users who may not have control on their browsers due to IT policy? Or will you support a browser which has been abandoned by its vendor itself, knowing that users of that browser are at risk of viruses? Backwards compatibility vs security. As developers, we have to always fight conflicting tendencies of using shiny new technologies vs sticking to mature technology. Too much of the former leads to hype driven development where teams keep rewriting the product in framework du jour instead of solving business problems. Too much of the later may lead to security issues as the technology itself stops being maintained.

Collapse
 
pbeekums profile image
Beekey Cheung

This is a pretty important idea, glad you wrote this post. I also hated Javascript for the longest time. Probably went through all the stages of grief and never quite got to acceptance until recently. I think what I really hated wasn't Javascript itself, it was the way it interacted with HTML/CSS that felt really hacky. Now we have stuff like ReactJS, Vue, and Polymer, that make everything programmatic and more like traditional software development.

I also found that often times it isn't the technology that's the problem. It's the software built with that technology. PHP was an awful language for the longest time, but the latest versions have made significant improvements. Yet the biggest PHP projects run on stuff like Drupal and Wordpress which are still terrible technologies. Java is also not so terrible a language, but Java projects tend to be extremely over-engineered which colors our perception of the language itself.

All that being said, Python and/or Go are still my languages of choice for server side work :)

Collapse
 
jonrgroverlib profile image
jonrgrover • Edited

Sometimes the wrong idea becomes the right idea. I am an advocate of 'worst practices'. i.e. those practices that are obviously bad, but that programmers tend to use anyway. Often there is a kernel of intuitive excellence in bad practices. If you can extract/separate the kernel of excellence from the bad practice, then you can use it by itself and do things other programmers can not. I've done that. It works. And now I can do things that others can not because I allowed the bad practices in my development until I understood the underlying truth. Then I ditch the bad practices, and leverage the truth discovered.

Collapse
 
zeddotes profile image
zeddotes

I think the human race, on every scale from a person to an online community, behaves in a pendulum. Ideas are banished and old ones are revisited due to newer infrastructure, innovations are done, ideas are banished.

Collapse
 
perttisoomann profile image
Pert Soomann

Right and wrong in the title are a bit too strong.

But I agree that over time the outside factors changes and some issues become non-issues.

Having to compile your resources into single JS / CSS / image file is good example, as this does not offend anyone's choice of language or framework.

Because internet speeds improved and underlining web technology improved too, you could look at it from completely different point of view and maybe split files up based on functionality so you don't accidentally expose something that should be available for limited users.

Actually I believe now the rad thing is to have CSS that handles only above the fold HTML, and another CSS file for the rest.

The problem is when people use these "best practice" lists not understanding the underlining reasoning and not factoring in their own project use cases, but it's even worse when they start rolling eyes when someone isn't doing it exactly like they do.

The beauty of development is, at least for me, there is no 1 right answer.

Also I've noticed when you are feeling stressed about your tech-stack loosing popularity, just wait 5-10 years, and your technology will be "in" again, and you can be leading expert :D

Collapse
 
jfrankcarr profile image
Frank Carr • Edited

Same here. There's a lot of legacy corporate code out there that's driving this. Old ColdFusion and ASP.NET web apps that won't run on newer browsers, especially Chrome, are a significant part.

Collapse
 
guitarkat profile image
Kat

Yeah I can see why for legacy stuff, but when they push for awesome new stuff but then go... IE8 or IE7..... .....

Collapse
 
imben1109 profile image
Ben

JavaScript bring me to paradise and hell. I do not know where I am.

I just think of TypeScript when JavaScript appears. I do not know why.

Collapse
 
joshualjohnson profile image
Joshua Johnson

This seems to be the pattern of life. I remember those day! But here we are.

Collapse
 
giantapia3 profile image
gian tapia

gracias por todo me fue de mucha ayuda para proyectos que tenia pendiente y no me salia , y gracias a la información de la pagina y algunos comentarios pude resolverlo.
webuniversal.pe/

Collapse
 
dance2die profile image
Sung M. Kim

Having to manage a VB6 app with browser that opens IE8 has been painful...

Migration to remove VB6 app has been going on surely but very slowly.

Collapse
 
revskill10 profile image
Truong Hoang Dung • Edited

NodeJS is really a revolution of technology in human being history, just like any technological revolutionary before it.
It's still not late for you to recognize and adapt it.