DEV Community

Cover image for Building in the Shadows: The Programming Languages Powering Dark Web Sites on Tor
404_CHRONICLES
404_CHRONICLES

Posted on

Building in the Shadows: The Programming Languages Powering Dark Web Sites on Tor

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only. The creation of dark web marketplaces or any platform facilitating illegal activities is highly illegal and unethical. Engaging in such practices can lead to severe legal consequences, including imprisonment. The goal here is to understand the technologies behind these websites to promote cybersecurity and awareness. Always use your knowledge responsibly and within the boundaries of the law.

In the realm of the dark web, a handful of marketplaces gained infamy for facilitating the sale of illegal items, from drugs to counterfeit goods. These sites, accessed through the anonymous Tor network, became notorious for their vast underground economies and illicit transactions. Here's an overview of the top five most famous dark web marketplaces:

Silk Road (2011-2013): The pioneer of dark web marketplaces, Silk Road revolutionized illegal online trade by creating a hidden platform primarily for drug sales. It operated using Bitcoin, promising anonymous transactions. Its founder, Ross Ulbricht, was eventually captured, and the FBI seized the site in 2013, marking one of the most high-profile dark web takedowns.

AlphaBay (2014-2017):
After Silk Road's demise, AlphaBay quickly became the largest marketplace, offering everything from narcotics and firearms to stolen data. It also used cryptocurrency for transactions. In 2017, AlphaBay was shut down by an international law enforcement operation, and its founder, Alexandre Cazes, was arrested.

Hansa Market (2015-2017):
Known for illegal drug sales and hacked accounts, Hansa Market gained traction after AlphaBay’s closure. However, it was secretly taken over by Dutch police in 2017, allowing them to gather information on users before shutting it down.

Dream Market (2013-2019):
Dream Market followed AlphaBay's fall, quickly becoming one of the go-to platforms for illegal trade. It hosted a wide range of products, from drugs to counterfeit documents. Dream Market voluntarily shut down in 2019, citing increasing law enforcement pressure.

Wall Street Market (2016-2019):
A significant player in the dark web ecosystem, Wall Street Market offered illegal drugs, weapons, and stolen credit card information. In 2019, it was taken down in a law enforcement sting, making headlines due to the large volume of users and transactions.

When it comes to developing dark web marketplaces, particularly those hosted on the Tor network, the tech stack typically involves a combination of languages and technologies that emphasize anonymity, security, and efficiency. These websites operate with a high level of complexity, requiring robust backend and frontend development to handle everything from user interactions to cryptocurrency transactions, all while minimizing the risk of detection by law enforcement.

Backend Development
Backend development is the core engine of any dark web marketplace. It is responsible for handling sensitive data, such as user accounts, transactions, and encrypted communications. For these types of sites, backend languages are chosen for their ability to support high scalability, security, and cryptographic functionalities. The most common backend languages used include:

  1. PHP
    PHP is often used in the backend for its ease of use, availability of numerous libraries, and ability to handle web applications efficiently. It’s common in the dark web because of its simplicity and the ease with which developers can set up server-side logic to manage user requests. However, security can be a concern with PHP if not handled properly. Websites like Silk Road and AlphaBay used PHP in their early iterations, leveraging its simplicity but relying on external libraries and frameworks to secure sensitive data.

  2. Python
    Python is frequently used for backend development in dark web marketplaces because of its flexibility and rich ecosystem of cryptographic libraries. Django or Flask frameworks are often employed to create scalable web applications. Python’s ability to easily integrate cryptographic modules like PyCryptodome allows developers to handle encrypted communication, manage secure user authentication, and conduct cryptocurrency transactions securely. Python’s versatility also makes it suitable for other dark web functions, such as scraping data from hidden services or managing automated cryptocurrency payments.

  3. Ruby
    Although not as common as PHP or Python, Ruby on Rails is another framework used for its strong security focus and quick development cycle. Ruby provides built-in libraries that can handle encryption and security protocols, making it ideal for developers building dark web markets that require anonymity and security. Some platforms have chosen Ruby for its high productivity in prototyping and agile development, allowing them to quickly launch new features or make changes in response to law enforcement pressure.

  4. JavaScript (Node.js)
    Node.js, with its non-blocking, event-driven architecture, is often used for developing scalable applications on the dark web. Its ability to handle a high volume of simultaneous connections is crucial for dark web marketplaces that deal with many users at any given time. Express.js, a popular Node.js framework, is used to create lightweight, fast web servers that can handle requests, such as browsing products or initiating cryptocurrency payments. In combination with MongoDB, a NoSQL database, Node.js can manage large datasets, such as marketplace listings or user profiles, while offering fast query responses.

  5. Java
    Java is sometimes employed due to its robustness and scalability. Though less common than Python or PHP, Java is trusted in environments where high-performance computing and large-scale applications are required. Java’s strong type system and vast array of frameworks (like Spring Boot) provide secure options for developing complex backend systems, especially when handling sensitive data like Bitcoin addresses or Monero transactions. Java is also known for its resilience against certain classes of vulnerabilities (e.g., buffer overflows) that might make other languages more vulnerable.

Database Management
The backend of dark web websites often involves a combination of secure databases for storing critical data, such as:

MySQL or MariaDB: Traditional relational databases that offer strong support for structured data. They’re often used in combination with PHP or Python applications to store user data, product listings, and transaction records.

MongoDB: A NoSQL database is often used alongside Node.js for its scalability and ability to handle unstructured data, such as messages or encrypted records.

PostgreSQL: Known for its strong support for encryption and security features, PostgreSQL is favored when strong cryptographic measures are needed. It’s especially useful in marketplaces where transaction data is encrypted and anonymized before being stored.

All these databases are typically stored in hidden, hardened server environments designed to resist both digital and physical threats.

Frontend Development
While the backend is critical, the frontend must also be designed with the same level of care, ensuring that it maintains anonymity and security while offering a user-friendly interface.

  1. HTML/CSS
    HTML and CSS form the backbone of the front end of dark web websites. Given the underground nature of these sites, designs tend to be simplistic and minimalistic, focusing more on functionality than aesthetics. The emphasis is on fast-loading, lightweight pages that can handle low-bandwidth Tor connections.

  2. JavaScript
    JavaScript plays a crucial role in enhancing user interactivity. Since dark web marketplaces need to provide basic functionalities like product searches, filtering, and cart management without compromising user anonymity, client-side JavaScript is often used minimally. Complex JavaScript frameworks like React or Angular are usually avoided because they could leak unnecessary data or increase the attack surface. However, simple JavaScript functionality may be used to facilitate smoother user interactions, such as AJAX calls for dynamic content updates without reloading the page.

  3. jQuery
    Older technologies like jQuery are often still in use on the dark web due to their simplicity. It’s lightweight and can handle basic client-side tasks, such as form validation and dynamic content loading, without introducing the complexity of modern front-end frameworks. jQuery is also easy to obfuscate, making it harder for malicious actors to analyze the site’s front end.

Security and Encryption
Regardless of the languages and frameworks used, security is paramount when developing dark web sites. Here’s how developers typically secure these marketplaces:

PGP Encryption: Pretty Good Privacy (PGP) is used to encrypt communications between buyers and sellers. Messages on dark web sites are often shared as PGP-encrypted blocks to ensure that even if the website is compromised, user messages remain unreadable.

SSL/TLS Encryption: Even though these sites operate over Tor, which encrypts traffic by default, developers still implement SSL/TLS certificates to ensure double-layer encryption, especially for sensitive data.

Two-Factor Authentication (2FA): Some dark web marketplaces incorporate 2FA to secure user logins, further enhancing the protection of user accounts from unauthorized access.

Monero Integration: Dark web marketplaces are increasingly integrating Monero (XMR) over Bitcoin due to its enhanced privacy features. Monero's protocol conceals transaction details, making it extremely difficult to trace payments.

IP and Location Masking: These websites also incorporate IP masking and the use of proxies to anonymize both users and servers. Backend languages like Python often integrate with Tor APIs to route all requests and responses through the Tor network.

Conclusion
Building dark web websites, particularly on Tor, requires a carefully selected tech stack that prioritizes anonymity, security, and performance. Backend languages like PHP, Python, Ruby, Java, and Node.js are common due to their flexibility, scalability, and availability of libraries supporting encryption and secure communication. On the frontend, minimal JavaScript, combined with HTML/CSS, ensures user interactions are smooth and lightweight while maintaining a high degree of anonymity.

By combining these technologies with strong cryptographic protocols, these sites can function securely in a space where privacy is essential, and security risks are ever-present. However, these tech stacks must evolve continually to adapt to new security threats and law enforcement techniques aimed at dismantling these networks.

The Hidden Code: Unveiling the Technology Behind Infamous Dark Web Marketplaces

Silk Road:
Backend: Silk Road was primarily developed using PHP due to its ease of setup and flexibility. It also relied on MySQL for database management, handling sensitive data like user accounts and transactions. For handling cryptographic operations and Bitcoin transactions, custom libraries were likely used alongside PHP.
Frontend: The frontend was minimalistic, built using basic HTML/CSS and some JavaScript to enhance user interaction. Given the simplicity of Tor connections, the site avoided heavy scripts, keeping page load times fast.

AlphaBay:
Backend: AlphaBay used Python (with frameworks like Flask or Django) for its backend. Python’s flexibility and its rich cryptographic library ecosystem made it ideal for handling complex operations like cryptocurrency transactions. The marketplace also utilized PostgreSQL as its database system to manage large datasets.
Frontend: Similar to Silk Road, AlphaBay employed HTML, CSS, and minimal JavaScript to keep things functional and light for users accessing via Tor. jQuery was used sparingly to enable dynamic features such as product searches or filtering.

Dream Market:
Backend: Dream Market relied heavily on Java for its backend, due to its scalability and security features. Spring Boot was likely used for managing server-side logic, along with MongoDB as a NoSQL database to handle user and product listings.
Frontend: The frontend was minimalistic, with HTML/CSS forming the basis of its structure. Like its predecessors, it avoided heavy JavaScript usage to maintain anonymity and security, with only light JavaScript to handle basic interactivity.

Hansa Market:
Backend: Hansa Market used PHP as its core backend language, alongside MySQL for database management. Given its focus on transactions and user security, it also implemented strong encryption libraries and protocols, particularly for messaging and account protection.
Frontend: The frontend was straightforward, relying on HTML, CSS, and light JavaScript to enhance the user experience without compromising security. Much like other marketplaces, Hansa kept its design lean to ensure fast page loading times over the Tor network.

Wall Street Market:
Backend: Node.js was the primary language used for Wall Street Market’s backend, with its non-blocking architecture supporting a high number of simultaneous connections. The site also used MongoDB for its database needs, managing large datasets such as user records, listings, and transactions.
Frontend: Wall Street Market employed basic HTML/CSS with JavaScript and AJAX for real-time updates like product listings and user messages. The frontend was designed to be lightweight and quick to ensure ease of use through Tor's often slower network.

Across these dark web platforms, the focus was on minimalistic, efficient design, strong encryption, and anonymous transaction handling. The combination of technologies, especially backend systems, was aimed at balancing performance and privacy while evading law enforcement and maintaining user anonymity.

Top comments (0)