DEV Community

Discussion on: PHP Typed Properties: Think Twice.

Collapse
mcfedr profile image
Fred Cox

no, you've gained the option of doing anything else at the point of get and set - you can change your implementation - you can refactor your field into something different and maintain your existing interface. a public field is just that, once its there you can never remove it.

Thread Thread
jorgecc profile image
Jorge Castro • Edited

In my experience, to hide logic in the getter or setter is dangerous because nobody would expect something there (unless it is a visual object such a button or textbox). So, finally, the getter and setters are a dummy.

Proof, C# has properties, they are a dummy but they are short & easy to write.

int MyProp {set; get;}