DEV Community

Discussion on: Angular vs Svelte - Card Component

Collapse
 
gc_psk profile image
Giancarlo Buomprisco

Counting characters to compare a fairly simple components is way too naive as a comparison: I do like both Angular and Svelte, so I don't think I am biased when I say this. I'd like to see the comparison of two full-blown complex, real world apps. Only then we can probably compare them.

Collapse
 
johncarroll profile image
John Carroll

Well, as someone who's only familiar with Angular, I can say that I find these comparisons interesting and useful.

But for folks like you, there's a website delivering exactly what you're asked for: github.com/gothinkster/realworld

Collapse
 
gc_psk profile image
Giancarlo Buomprisco • Edited

I agree: they're useful, I made one myself, but I wouldn't use counting characters as a metric for comparison. There's so much more in an application than components, which in my opinion are the "easy" part. The real world app you link is hardly one: I'm talking enterprise, resilient, rock-solid stuff. Probably not something you can find in the open, I admit.

Thread Thread
 
mauro_codes profile image
Mauro Garcia

I think your point is valid, but not all the apps are enterprise or super complex. And, for those kind of apps it's helpful to see this kind of comparisons. Btw, I love Angular and I'm using it on most of my projects.

As I said on previous posts, I'm just starting with Svelte and Sapper. Maybe in the feature I'll be comparing more complex stuff, but this series are all about components.

They are probably the easy part, but they are also a big part of the code we write every date.

Collapse
 
mauro_codes profile image
Mauro Garcia

Glad it was useful for you! 😄

Collapse
 
Sloan, the sloth mascot
Comment deleted
Collapse
 
gc_psk profile image
Giancarlo Buomprisco

As I said in another comment, that's hardly a real world app. A more complex todo app at best.