DEV Community

Discussion on: Opensource... NO more free?!

Collapse
 
elvisoric profile image
Elvis Oric

You write code for free. They use it to train their AI and potentially you are the buyer of your own code.

Collapse
 
moopet profile image
Ben Sinclair

If you want everyone to have access to your code, "everyone" includes people you don't like.

If the license says they can copy and redistribute it then that's exactly what they can do - and that's your choice as a software author.

You're perfectly free to make a license that says your code can only be used by people or companies with less than $1,000,000 turnover if you want, but bigness and richness don't always correlate well with any one person's idea of "morally good".

Collapse
 
link2twenty profile image
Andrew Bone

You hire a person, you train them on your code and potentially you are paying the wages of someone reproducing your code.

Collapse
 
computergeek profile image
Amrut

That is the problem, we have to pay for our code

Thread Thread
 
link2twenty profile image
Andrew Bone

But you're not paying for your code. You're paying for the resources to run an AI assistant that has gleamed understanding from looking at lots of code examples.

Thread Thread
 
computergeek profile image
Amrut

Andrew, there are people like you and me who write code in our own repository on github, microsoft is giving those code for copilot training for their profit.

Thread Thread
 
link2twenty profile image
Andrew Bone • Edited

What about companies that sell products that use React? That's open source and the companies make profit.

Collapse
 
elvisoric profile image
Elvis Oric

My opinion is that every developer should be able to choose whether his code can be used in AI or not. And Microsoft or any other company that offers tool similar to copilot should respect that and other licenses

Thread Thread
 
computergeek profile image
Amrut

Yes, that would be great