DEV Community

Discussion on: Components are Pure Overhead

Collapse
 
dannyengelman profile image
Danny Engelman • Edited

The most important aspect all these discussions forget is:

It has NOTHING to do with technology

In august 2019 the W3C and WHATWG agreed the WHATWG would be in the lead on Web development.
The W3C will only give the final "its a standard" approval.

The WHATWG is By-inivitation-only
And to date, Apple, Google, Mozilla and Microsoft haven't invited Facebook yet.

and it is ALL about technology

This means no single company can get away with single-company dominanting technologies

If you follow the threads, you see 4 companies more and more working better together,
something I have never seen in my 31 active Internet years.
And ofcourse they are slow... they all have to agree. I can't even agree with my wife on everything.

So/but the "V1 Web Components" standard (V0 was a Google party, not a standard) will only get better

And yes, Facebook "owns" 60-70% of the Front-End market, and doesn't even mention Web Component technology in the last React release.

  • Once AltaVista owned the search market

  • Once IE had 90% of the Browser market

  • Once Flash was installed on every device

React is the new Cobol

Thread Thread
 
peerreynders profile image
peerreynders

The WHATWG is By-invitation-only
And to date, Apple, Google, Mozilla and Microsoft haven't invited Facebook yet.

Apple (WebKit), Google (Blink), Mozilla (Gecko), Microsoft (Trident/EdgeHTML), Facebook (?).

  • Given this situation what does Facebook have to contribute?
  • Facebook has no interest in browser-engines. As far as they're concerned the Web could burn down tomorrow and they would happily continue making native clients for every platform under the sun.

So/but the "V1 Web Components" standard ... will only get better.

I think the point you are trying to make is that Web Components are a standard while React is not.

However not all standards are adopted by the industry as a whole.

Example:

Do not use this application cache feature! It is in the process of being removed from the Web platform - Using the application cache

AppCache: Douchebag

Also from the article's author: Maybe Web Components are not the Future?

React merely has a visible, vocal support base - which makes its component model seem popular.

And yes, Facebook "owns" 60-70% of the Front-End market.

With reference to what 100%?

React is used by 2.5% of all the websites whose JavaScript library we know. This is 2.0% of all websites.

Usage statistics and market share of React for websites

Top 1m 10.26%
Top 100k 22.42%
Top 10k 39.25%

React Usage Statistics

Top 1m 75.42%
Top 100k 80.9%
Top 10k 79.62%

jQuery Usage Statistics

Top 1m 44.06%
Top 100k 49.22%
Top 10k 52.91%

PHP Usage Statistics

React is the new Cobol