I accidentally turned on RBP without realizing what it does fully, and while I'd usually like a feature like this, it's "negative-helpful" for me, especially if I'm using obscure programs, or ones that have no reputation.
But after enabling it, it doesn't give me the option to turn it off.
Discussion (2)
I guess by enabling it you enable a bunch of options in the "Reputation-based protection settings" tab. You can go there and disable them.
There's one I couldn't disable, it'd flicker back on, and I don't think that's fully how it worked.
Though, after some rutting around, I found a sufficient answer that (surprisingly) worked.