DEV Community

loading...
Cover image for Quick A/B Poll: Which card style you like better?

Quick A/B Poll: Which card style you like better?

alvarosaburido profile image Alvaro Saburido Updated on ・2 min read

UPDATE 10/08/2020:

Thanks to everyone that took the time to vote and provide valuable feedback in this poll. You guys rock 🤘.

I decided to use Option A (even if B got more votes 🦄) with a few changes inspired by the feedback you gave me and considering the component surroundings:

Alt Text

Card A is the real deal (dark background, vibrant colors, etc., all evoke the feelings of competition, passion, aggression, etc.).
by @AnkushThakur

I added the character names, the logos in the bg similar to option B, and I added a small indicator of the stage just at the top.

I like the contrast that the card gives, it's eye-catching in all that light tournament page and clearly invites the user to check the next battle kinda feeling.

Here is another version of it

Alt Text

And how it looks in the same tournament page but in knockout phase:

Alt Text

Does that mean I threw the Option B to the trash 🗑? Not really, I actually going to use it on a page with historical of matches, because there doesn't need that much dynamism and contrast looks nice and clean.

I'm really happy with the result. and all the cool discussions happening on the comments, thanks, everyone!


Hi there 👋 . I'm a big fan of Super Smash Bros since I was a little kid.

Alt Text

I'm doing some quick design for a tournament app in Vue and I could use your feedback, which card you like the most?.

  • Option A: Vote heart ❤️
  • Option B: Vote 🦄

Disclaimer: Characters and names are property of Nintendo of America.

Discussion

pic
Editor guide
Collapse
daniel13rady profile image
Daniel Brady

Tough choice, they both look good! But I’ll go with option B, because the design elements more closely align with Nintendo, in my mind: clean, slanted, character logos as shadows of the characters, etc.

One suggestion: try making the “Finish Battle” text in ALL-CAPS and see how that changes the feel of it.

Collapse
alvarosaburido profile image
Alvaro Saburido Author

Thanks for the feedback, really apprieciate it.

Collapse
johntalamo profile image
JohnTalamo

They're both good but I prefer A. My eyes went right to that one. The colors pop and the characters look like they're more 3-D versus looking more 2-D on white.

Collapse
alvarosaburido profile image
Alvaro Saburido Author

I have the same feeling, I'm trying to step away from my overall romance with minimalistic white interfaces with something riskier

Collapse
zfett profile image
Zachary Fetters

🦄 - Both look absolutely amazing, but I'm leaning more towards B! I agree with what @daniel13rady said: it more matches the simple and clean aesthetic of Nintendo's style. If I could recommend a slight change to A to make it better (even though it is pretty sleek!), I would make the dark blue background behind the characters a bit more subdued, more towards #414754, and make the "VS" icon flat-styled, while still retaining the same colors and general shape. I hope this feedback makes sense!

Collapse
dabit_coder profile image
David Oliva Tirado

They are both awesome! But I think that the white one looks a bit better. It's less overloaded with things (the logos behind the characters are SICK) and in general looks more clean and elegant.

Really good job!

Collapse
huncyrus profile image
huncyrus

This is hard, because like elements from each side.

I like the format of the B:

  • Rounded corners
  • Full figures
  • Figure logo as background
  • Name written down

And I like from the "A":

  • Colors
  • "vs" artwork (i know, littlebit copied from street fighter)
  • The red rounded button from below for finishing a battle

The second one because focus more the important UI elements and has better call-to-action feelin' (e.g.: drive better the eye what to do, more intuitive).
The first one way cleaner by feeling.

Would be interesting to have both scheme for dark/light theme ;)

Collapse
horrorofpartybeach profile image
Emma

I really like both designs but I went for Option A because I find it easier to read/see things against a darker background. I'd suggest increasing the contrast of some of the icons on the bottom black banner of Option A; from an accessibility point of view, this would be a great improvement.

I also really like the shadows behind Falco and Link on Option B and I agree with Daniel that this design is more closely aligned with Nintendo.

Great job on the designs, they're both awesome!

Collapse
nombrekeff profile image
Manolo Edge

I like B more, but would like A if they used the same styling (ie. rounder borders, shadows, and badge)

Collapse
lmioco profile image
lmioco

I prefer the second one

Collapse
dko1905 profile image
Daniel Florescu

I like option B, but I think a dark version B, would look even better.

Collapse
alvarosaburido profile image
Alvaro Saburido Author

Not a bad idea tho, thanks for replying

Collapse
alexanderjanke profile image
Alex Janke

🦄
(but reducing the shadow just a little bit)

Collapse
alvarosaburido profile image
Alvaro Saburido Author

Hey thanks for the awesome feedback, I totally get your point actually I didn't put any names because I wasn't happy how the fonts looked on it, I still trying to find the correct font to it.

Collapse
joelbonetr profile image
JoelBonetR

I love the way characters goes out of the card and the darker "footer" on A, but I love the information about wins and character names, and also the finish battle style on B 😂

Collapse
ddiatlov profile image
Dimitry Diatlov

Both are great, but I like style B more. The rounded edges and the shadows in combination with the white background make it more eye-catching.

Collapse
fkhadra profile image
Fadi Khadra

Both are gorgeous. But I would go for A. The "VS" is really eye-catching. Would you share the app when done ?

Collapse
alvarosaburido profile image
Alvaro Saburido Author

Thank you very much, yes Im planning on having a demo version of the app with mock data on my portfolio site, :D.

Collapse
xukinorris profile image
Xukinorris

I always go for the clean that uses the least dark colors. Nice job btw!

Collapse
samwightt profile image
Sam Wight

Option B with Option A's button looks esp good to me! Not sure the button design looks like a button or matches with the rounded corners.

Collapse
andrewbaisden profile image
Andrew Baisden

A has more colour and B looks subdued and simple. Both look good however A looks like it belongs in a AAA game whereas B looks like it was made for a more simple clone of a AAA game in my opinion.

Collapse
becoolie4u2 profile image
becoolie4u2

🦄 but make the "vs" a little bigger and I second a dark version as well.

Collapse
generalboomstick profile image
Andrew Corsini

These both look amazing!! I'm a dark mode guy myself, so I'm more inclined towards A, but I think either one would be a great fit. Nice Work!

Collapse
patarapolw profile image
Pacharapol Withayasakpunt

❤️

I do prefer light mode better, but Option A provides more colorfulness and contrast.

Collapse
darkwiiplayer profile image
DarkWiiPlayer

I'mma go with B, but not by much. They are both pretty cool :D

Collapse
markoshiva profile image
Marko Shiva Pavlovic

Option A is far better.

Collapse
dothtm profile image
Midpoint Nerd

Depends entirely on the background, as presented on white, then A.

But on a dark background, I suspect B.

Collapse
lukeofficial profile image
Luke

❤️

Collapse
sarcasmappreciated profile image
Benson Li

B is cleaner and more easily descipherable

Collapse
gabrielrufino profile image
Collapse
virenb profile image
Collapse
bidetaggle profile image
Collapse
harikayedidi profile image
Harika Yedidi

🦄 IMO B highlights the characters and is more neat looking than A, especially with the CTA.

Collapse
didacsf profile image