DEV Community


Discussion on: Agency VS Product Company: Which One's Right for You?

alli profile image
Alli Teration Author

Not everyone’s experience is going to be the same as my own. This was mostly true at the agency I worked for and the product company I work for now. (I did say “usually” and noted an exception that’s similar to what you described.)

Let’s say both companies have frontend engineers that are really interested in using Vue. They’ve researched and decided Vue is the best frontend framework at this time. (I’m not saying this is true; this is hypothetical.)

At the product company, the existing frontend codebases are all in React. The amount of effort to convert any one of them to Vue would be astronomical. The frontend would need to be entirely rewritten. The impact to users would be minor. Even if one was switched, it would mean frontend engineers at the company would need to be experts in both React and Vue. The product company’s best bet would be to start the next new product in Vue, but maybe the company’s more invested in improving old products than creating new ones. The likelihood that these engineers will be using Vue anytime soon is unlikely.

At the agency we used Angular. If we wanted to use Vue, we’d have to wait for a new project to start that Vue would be appropriate for. Given the rate of new projects coming in at the agency, this would probably take a few months. The new project could be done in Vue, and the engineers could reflect and determine if they want to continue and use Vue on the next project and or go back to Angular. (While I presented this as a hypothetical, this actually happened at the agency after I left. They use Vue now.)

But not every agency is just like the one I worked for—some clients might have more demands about what technology is used (see my example about the client that insisted on ASP.NET—but we were still able to use .NET Core in another project). Some product-based companies have more flexibility. There are also plenty of companies that don’t fit in the “agency” or “product company” boxes.

moopet profile image
Ben Sinclair

I've worked for several agencies and have friends who work for product companies and my experience is broadly the same as Alli's.

Sometimes in agencies you have to use a particular technology, sometimes you get to pick and choose. As long as you can justify it to management and the client, it's usually ok - but this includes the justification that it's ok to add yet another technology to the list you have to support.

Forem Open with the Forem app